Lawyer alleges contradictions in witness testimony in Lusikisiki mass murder

In the ongoing trial for the Lusikisiki mass murder, a defense lawyer has accused a state witness of contradicting himself during cross-examination. The case involves six men charged with killing 18 people in September 2024. The proceedings are taking place at the Mthatha High Court sitting in Lusikisiki.

The trial for the brutal killing of 18 people in Ngobozana village, Lusikisiki, Eastern Cape, in September 2024, continued at the Mthatha High Court. Six men face multiple murder charges related to the incident.

Advocate Mawande Nokhwali, representing accused number two Aphiwe Ndende, cross-examined state witness Lwando Abi, who was previously an accused. Nokhwali pointed out inconsistencies in Abi's statements. In his first statement, Abi described the firearms used in the killings as being in a bag, but in his confession, he said they were leaning against the wall.

Additionally, Nokhwali noted that Abi told police he called his wife after the shooting, whereas in another statement, he claimed his wife called him. Responding to the lawyer, Abi insisted, "I am sure I called my wife."

The case has been postponed until Monday next week to allow further proceedings. This development highlights the scrutiny on witness reliability in the high-profile mass murder case.

Related Articles

Nighttime crime scene outside murdered Madlanga Commission witness's Brakpan home, with police tape, chalk outline, and investigators amid flashing lights.
Image generated by AI

Murder of Madlanga Commission witness sparks security concerns

Reported by AI Image generated by AI

Marius van der Merwe, known as Witness D, was gunned down outside his home in Brakpan on Friday night after testifying about alleged police torture. The killing has prompted a national manhunt and vows from President Cyril Ramaphosa to strengthen whistleblower protections. Authorities are investigating possible links to his testimony or anti-illegal mining efforts.

In the Polokwane High Court, the defence lawyer for a man accused of murdering his wife has claimed that police planted the firearm found at his home to incriminate him. Fannie Seribishane faces charges related to the October 2024 shooting of nurse Mumsy Seribishane outside Lebowakgomo Hospital. The lawyer is seeking an acquittal for her client.

Reported by AI

The family of Emmanuel Mbense, tortured to death in 2022, is seeking clarity on Witness D's testimony at the Madlanga Commission. The witness, identified as Marius van der Merwe, was assassinated shortly after revealing details of a police operation linked to Mbense's death. Commissioners have visited van der Merwe's family amid growing concerns for witness safety.

The Thohoyandou High Court in Limpopo has delayed the sentencing of comedian and social media influencer Livhuwani Madadzhe until Friday due to conflicting legal applications he submitted.

Reported by AI

The Johannesburg High Court is set to deliver judgment on 5 February 2026 in businessman Suleiman Carrim's urgent bid to avoid testifying before the Madlanga Commission. The commission argues that granting relief would stifle its ability to compel witnesses in its probe into corruption within South Africa's police service. Carrim claims the commission has violated principles of fairness by singling him out.

Former IPID head Robert McBride testified on January 20, 2026, before Parliament's ad hoc committee, accusing KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi of attempting to undermine an investigation into former acting national commissioner Khomotso Phahlane. McBride described Mkhwanazi and Phahlane as close associates and highlighted inconsistencies in Mkhwanazi's involvement in the 2020 murder of IPID investigator Mandla Mahlangu. The testimony raises questions about internal rifts in South Africa's law enforcement amid broader allegations of cartel infiltration.

Reported by AI

North West Premier Lazarus Mokgosi has denied claims of interfering in a municipal appointment, calling them part of a political smear campaign. He made these statements while testifying before a provincial committee investigating the allegations. The claims stem from a 2023 incident involving a report on a municipal manager's hiring.

 

 

 

This website uses cookies

We use cookies for analytics to improve our site. Read our privacy policy for more information.
Decline