Ryan Murphy's new Hulu series 'All's Fair,' starring Kim Kardashian as a divorce attorney, premiered its first three episodes on November 4, 2025, to overwhelmingly negative reviews. Critics described the show as dull, clumsy, and potentially the worst TV drama ever, though Sarah Paulson's performance drew some praise. The series follows an all-female law firm handling high-stakes divorces in Los Angeles.
Release Details
'All's Fair' debuted on Hulu with its first three episodes on Tuesday, November 4, 2025. New episodes will stream weekly on Tuesdays. The 10-episode legal drama is also available on Disney+. Kim Kardashian stars as Allura Grant, the owner of an all-women divorce law firm inspired by celebrity attorney Laura Wasser, who represented Kardashian in her divorces. Kardashian executive produces alongside her mother, Kris Jenner, and Ryan Murphy.
Cast and Plot
The ensemble includes Naomi Watts as Liberty Ronson, Niecy Nash-Betts as Emerald Greene, Glenn Close as Dina Standish, and Teyana Taylor. Sarah Paulson plays rival attorney Carrington Lane, a bitter former colleague who antagonizes the firm. The series centers on the team's navigation of courtroom battles, scandals, and internal dynamics while representing female clients in wealthy divorces. Guest stars include Judith Light as a sassy socialite, Elizabeth Berkley as a scorned scientist, and Jessica Simpson as a revenge-seeking plastic surgery victim.
Critical Reception
The show has earned a 0% score on Rotten Tomatoes and 11% on Metacritic, signaling overwhelming dislike. The Hollywood Reporter called it 'unforgivably dull,' criticizing Kardashian's 'stiff and affectless' performance and the 'bland' dialogue. Variety labeled the storytelling 'clumsy' and the feminist messaging 'condescending.' The Times of London deemed it 'the worst TV drama ever,' a 0-star 'tacky and revolting monument to greed.' The Guardian's Lucy Mangan gave it 0 stars, calling it 'fascinatingly, existentially terrible' with 'expressionless' acting across the board. The Telegraph's Ed Power awarded one star, branding it a 'crime against television' and noting the cast's overall poor performances. USA Today's Kelly Lawler called it the worst show of the year, with scripts 'worse than what Chat GPT was spitting out two years ago.'
However, TVLine highlighted Paulson's 'phenomenally unhinged' portrayal of Carrington as the 'saving grace,' likening her to a swearing Sue Sylvester from 'Glee' and praising her handling of profanity. This marks Kardashian's second collaboration with Murphy after 'American Horror Story: Delicate,' which scored 77% on Rotten Tomatoes and received some acclaim for her role.
