The Toronto Blue Jays are poised for a significant offseason move, weighing whether to re-sign shortstop Bo Bichette or pursue outfielder Kyle Tucker. MLB insider Keegan Matheson outlines the cases for both players amid speculation about the team's payroll flexibility. General manager Ross Atkins emphasized Bichette's value to the franchise.
The Toronto Blue Jays have an opportunity to make a splash in free agency this offseason, but the decision hinges on whether they prioritize re-signing their own Bo Bichette or targeting Houston's Kyle Tucker.
In a recent article, MLB.com's Keegan Matheson detailed the appeal of Tucker, whose potential contract could exceed $300 million. Matheson described Tucker as embodying 'Blue Jays baseball' with all attributes turned up high, noting him as a rock-solid hitter leading the market. However, the Blue Jays plan to engage but not overpay, given their payroll flexibility beyond 2025 levels. Ownership, having experienced deep postseason runs, is unlikely to revert to conservative spending.
Bichette, a longtime cornerstone, brings emotional weight to the decision, reminiscent of last year's Vladimir Guerrero Jr. extension talks. General manager Ross Atkins praised him at the GM Meetings: 'A great player. Bo has been a significant part of us being in a strong position today. He’s a reason that we’re coming off of five solid seasons of baseball and one really, really good year of baseball. He’s had a lot to do with it. I know he’s going to be attractive to the market, and we’ll be in his market.' Bichette's market value varies widely, and while the team is open to him at shortstop, Matheson suggests a stronger lineup with Bichette at second base and Andrés Giménez at short.
Speculation exists about acquiring both, but Matheson indicates it's improbable due to the massive salary increase. The Blue Jays must balance needs, wants, and roster spots in what could be an exciting winter.