Sarah Paulson has been named TVLine's Performer of the Week for her standout role as Carrington Lane in Episode 5 of Hulu's All's Fair. The episode, titled 'This Is Me Trying' and aired on November 18, 2025, delved deeply into her character's personal struggles and vulnerabilities. Paulson's performance blended humor, heartbreak, and nuance, earning praise for its emotional depth.
Performance Overview
In the first four episodes of All's Fair, Sarah Paulson's character, Carrington Lane, served as a sharp-tongued side figure, delivering witty barbs to the main lawyers. Episode 5 shifted focus to Carrington, examining her life under intense scrutiny and showcasing Paulson's ability to portray a complex mix of comedy and tragedy.
Key Scenes
Paulson brought humor to a tense sobriety test, where Carrington swerves while singing 'Edge of Seventeen'—a nod to Stevie Nicks from her American Horror Story: Coven days—before facing a breathalyzer. Earlier, in a bizarre encounter with Chase, she washes his hair and deflects his advances with roasting commentary, creating a scene full of unpredictability.
The episode explored Carrington's strained bond with her daughter Amabel, played by Juliette Mae Diamond. A poignant moment occurs as Carrington helps Amabel craft a school essay on perseverance, revealing how her sharp words impacted her child. Paulson captured the character's desire to improve while hindered by her flaws.
Another highlight involves Carrington visiting her ex-husband Sebastian, portrayed by Jason Butler Harner. Their conversation revisits a marriage of convenience, leading to Carrington admitting she needs help. Subtle interactions with Lorraine Toussaint's Alberta Dome provided additional emotional layers, as Alberta offers the first real support.
Honorable Mentions
TVLine also recognized Gary Cole for his comedic turn as billionaire Brad Vinick in Episode 3 of Netflix's A Man on the Inside, and Demi Moore for her commanding presence in the Season 2 premiere of Landman.
This recognition highlights Paulson's versatility in elevating a supporting role to the forefront.