Free-agent outfielder Kyle Tucker could decide on a new team as soon as Thursday, with the Mets, Blue Jays, and Dodgers as frontrunners following last week's emergence of New York as a top suitor. The Mets have a reported four-year offer averaging $50 million annually, while Toronto eyes up to 10 years at a lower AAV.
Since last week's reports solidified the Mets, Dodgers, and Blue Jays as frontrunners for Tucker—the top remaining free agent—the situation has accelerated. Multiple sources indicate a decision is imminent, potentially Thursday, January 15, amid a thinning market with only four of the top 12 free agents unsigned.
The 28-year-old Tucker, who posted a 4.5-WAR season in 2025 despite late-year hand and calf injuries, remains highly valued for his right-handed power (OPS+ 139 career) and outfield defense. The Mets' short-term, high-AAV proposal (per New York Post) would let him hit free agency again at 32. The Blue Jays, leveraging their recent World Series run and signings like Kazuma Okamoto, prefer a long-term commitment (up to 10 years, per Jeff Passan). The Dodgers aim to upgrade beyond Tommy Edman and Andy Pages.
Recent blockbuster deals—like Alex Bregman to the Cubs (5Y/$175M) and Ranger Suárez to the Red Sox (5Y/$130M)—have heightened urgency. Tucker's choice could spark moves: Toronto to the Mets/Dodgers might lead to Cody Bellinger pursuits, while a Mets/Dodgers signing could push the Jays toward Bo Bichette or other outfielders.