Hong Kong bar association proposes criminalizing bid-rigging after fire

The Hong Kong Bar Association has formed a task force following last month's deadly Tai Po fire, proposing targeted legislation to criminalize bid-rigging and make key construction safety guidelines legally binding. The blaze was the city's deadliest in seven decades, and bid-rigging is currently treated as serious anti-competitive conduct under the Competition Ordinance, punishable only by fines.

The Hong Kong Bar Association, led by chairman Jose-Antonio Maurellet, plans to propose targeted legislation to criminalize bid-rigging in response to the city's recent deadly fire. This follows the formation of a task force to review existing laws after the Tai Po blaze last month, which was Hong Kong's deadliest in seven decades.

Currently, bid-rigging is classified as 'serious anti-competitive conduct' under the Competition Ordinance and is punishable only by fines, not criminal penalties. "[Bid-rigging] is not in itself a criminal activity and therefore the punishment and the deterrence level may not be sufficient," Maurellet told the Post.

He added: "When we look at what has happened recently, then you realise that bid-rigging is not just sometimes about paying an extra five dollars or having a slightly less quality product. It can actually cost your life. It can actually harm you and harm your property."

Maurellet acknowledged the challenges in proving agreements among parties in bid-rigging cases but argued that specific legislation could help deter such practices. The association also intends to push for key construction safety guidelines, such as the Code of Practice for Fire Safety in Buildings and the Code of Practice for Bamboo Scaffolding Safety, to become legally binding, aiming to enhance industry standards and prevent future tragedies.

Related Articles

Hong Kong workers dismantle scaffolding safety nets from high-rises following deadly fire safety order.
Image generated by AI

Hong Kong firms remove scaffolding nets to meet deadline

Reported by AI Image generated by AI

Hong Kong authorities have ordered the removal of scaffolding nets at about 200 sites citywide following the deadly Tai Po fire, with firms starting work to meet a three-day deadline. Suspected false safety certificates were found at two building sites, prompting the measure to prevent repeats of the tragedy that claimed at least 159 lives.

Former senior project manager Raphael Chan has detailed rampant corruption in Hong Kong's construction industry, including bid-rigging syndicates linked to triads. He shared his experiences following the deadly Wang Fuk Court fire in Tai Po last month, which killed at least 161 people and prompted arrests tied to corruption and fraud. Chan has assisted the Independent Commission Against Corruption in probing such groups.

Reported by AI

After a deadly fire in Tai Po that claimed 168 lives, Hong Kong's government has proposed measures to strengthen building maintenance. Experts, however, warn that these pledges only scratch the surface of long-standing systemic issues in the sector.

Following the Wang Fuk Court blaze and removal of nets from 420 renovation sites, Secretary for Development Bernadette Linn has rejected extending accreditation requirements to suppliers, deeming it overreach, while welcoming a Construction Industry Council recommended supplier list.

Reported by AI

Hong Kong authorities are expediting updates to safety guidelines for elevated work platforms following the deaths of three workers in construction accidents. Secretary for Labour and Welfare Chris Sun has vowed swift action and a large-scale inspection campaign. The incidents highlight ongoing concerns over work-at-height safety.

Hong Kong's newly elected Legislative Council held its first meeting on January 15, led by president Starry Lee Wai-king, with Chief Executive John Lee outlining priorities for responding to the deadly Wang Fuk Court fire in Tai Po. Discussions centered on relief for displaced residents, rehousing, industry reforms, and anti-bid-rigging measures amid calls for accountability.

Reported by AI

An opinion piece stresses that thousands of ageing high-rises in Hong Kong will require repair work in the coming years, with responsibility for projects needing to be addressed amid reports of bid-rigging.

 

 

 

This website uses cookies

We use cookies for analytics to improve our site. Read our privacy policy for more information.
Decline