Idaho woman charged after shooting man who dared her during argument

Diane Wetherbee, 65, faces felony charges in Idaho after allegedly shooting a man in the leg with a .380 pistol he handed her during an argument while drinking. She then went to bed and fell asleep, according to court documents. Deputies arrested her after finding her sleeping at the scene.

On Saturday night in Challis, Idaho, Diane Wetherbee, 65, and a man were drinking at a home when they began arguing, according to court documents cited by Law&Crime and East Idaho News. The man reportedly handed Wetherbee a .380 pistol and told her to shoot him. She allegedly fired, striking him in the leg. Afterward, Wetherbee went to an upstairs bedroom and fell asleep. Another person at the home heard a single gunshot but did not witness the incident. Deputies responded to the residence around 11:23 p.m. and found Wetherbee sleeping. They took her into custody, and the pistol was located on the bedroom floor amid blood puddles. A search revealed additional blood and a pair of bloody boots near the back door. Wetherbee confessed to the shooting while en route to Custer County Jail, where she was booked. She has been charged with felony aggravated battery using a deadly weapon and is held on a $25,000 bond. A no-contact order requires her to stay away from the victim. Wetherbee is scheduled for a preliminary hearing on March 30 and faces up to 15 years in prison if convicted.

Related Articles

Illustration of a son claiming self-defense in a confrontation with his intoxicated father inside a rural Wyoming home.
Image generated by AI

Wyoming son charged with father's murder claims self-defense

Reported by AI Image generated by AI

Ethan Grasse, 23, faces second-degree murder charges after fatally shooting his father, Michael Grasse, 49, in Uinta County, Wyoming, in November 2025. He argues self-defense following a day of efforts to prevent his intoxicated father from driving and subsequent threats. A judge rejected dismissing the case but allowed the claim at trial.

A 44-year-old Michigan woman faces an open murder charge after allegedly shooting her 52-year-old boyfriend in the back of the head during an argument at their home. Jennifer Dana Moore called 911 on April 22, admitting she shot Joseph Wayne Worley, who died at the scene. She told investigators the revolver discharged accidentally as he walked away.

Reported by AI

Logan Dakota Stephens received a 20-year prison sentence for shooting a man who tried to protect a woman during an altercation in Idaho Falls. The Bonneville County Prosecuting Attorney's Office announced the sentencing this week after Stephens pleaded guilty to aggravated battery with a deadly weapon enhancement. The victim survived four gunshot wounds but faces lasting injuries.

An 80-year-old Wisconsin man has been charged with first-degree intentional homicide after fatally shooting his wife at a nature preserve near Baraboo. George Paul allegedly killed his 80-year-old wife Susan Paul before firing shots at a local police department.

Reported by AI

A 41-year-old woman in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, has been charged with first-degree intentional homicide after shooting and killing a 63-year-old man during an argument about delivery food. The incident stemmed from the victim's belief that someone had stolen his chicken order. Authorities say the woman admitted to the shooting but claimed she did not remember pulling the trigger.

A 21-year-old man in Indiana faces charges of reckless homicide after his wife died from a gunshot wound and their newborn baby was injured in what he initially described as an accident. Cameron E. Tomlinson claimed Jessica Tomlinson accidentally shot herself while handling a revolver, but later admitted he may have pulled the trigger. Authorities arrested him following interviews and evidence collection at their apartment.

Reported by AI

Brenwyn Richey, a 26-year-old mother from Blackfoot, Idaho, faces a felony charge of injury to a child after witnesses reported her shaking and jolting her one-week-old daughter like a rag doll. Police say Richey admitted to using excessive force, including aggressively bouncing the infant on her knee. The child showed signs of internal injuries and was removed from her home by Child Protective Services.

 

 

 

This website uses cookies

We use cookies for analytics to improve our site. Read our privacy policy for more information.
Decline