CDU General Secretary Carsten Linnemann has declared a mandatory community service year as his top priority. He argues that a voluntary approach fails to reach those who would benefit most, especially disadvantaged youth. Criticism comes from Die Linke and the Workers' Welfare Association.
Carsten Linnemann, CDU general secretary, called for a mandatory community service year in an interview with the Rheinische Post. He described it as his 'highest priority,' arguing that a purely voluntary approach would not reach many people. In particular, young individuals from difficult social environments who feel excluded would benefit without volunteering. Linnemann views it as a key to 'strengthen social cohesion sustainably.'
The debate has reignited amid discussions on conscription. The black-red coalition recently agreed on a military service reform that initially relies on voluntariness. President Frank-Walter Steinmeier expressed a similar view in early November, advocating for a mandatory service period for all: 'In my conviction, a mandatory period for everyone would be fairest in the long term, with some in the Bundeswehr and others in social areas.'
Opposition to the call for compulsion comes from Die Linke. Party co-chair Jan van Aken stated: 'I'm pleased that so many young people are eager to work in social projects for a year – we should promote that and not talk about coercion.' The party will vote against such a plan. The Workers' Welfare Association (AWO) also rejects it. President Michael Groß emphasized: 'Engagement cannot be prescribed.' Moreover, a mandatory year would overwhelm structures, as time is needed to expand support and deployment frameworks.