Illustration depicting Greens leader Felix Banaszak comparing US ICE agents to Nazi SA and SS during a podcast on Trump's deportation policies.
Illustration depicting Greens leader Felix Banaszak comparing US ICE agents to Nazi SA and SS during a podcast on Trump's deportation policies.
Gambar dihasilkan oleh AI

Greens leader Banaszak compares ICE agents to SA and SS

Gambar dihasilkan oleh AI

The co-chair of Germany's Greens party, Felix Banaszak, has compared the actions of the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to methods used by the Nazis. In a podcast, he sharply criticized President Donald Trump's deportation policies and warned of authoritarian tendencies. The comparison relates to deadly incidents in Minneapolis.

Felix Banaszak, co-chair of Germany's Greens party, spoke critically about US immigration policy in the podcast "Ronzheimer" hosted by Bild editor Paul Ronzheimer. He accused the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency of engaging in "dehumanization" by ripping people from their lives and deporting them. "Those who stand in their way just get shot," Banaszak said.

He compared the behavior of ICE agents to that of the Nazi paramilitary organizations SA (Sturmabteilung) and SS (Schutzstaffel) before Adolf Hitler's formal seizure of power in 1933. Banaszak stressed the need for caution with historical comparisons, but said the actions evoked such memories for him. He also criticized Trump for questioning the 2020 presidential election results, thereby rejecting democratic principles of peaceful power transfer.

Banaszak pointed to incidents in Minneapolis, Minnesota, where the US government deployed thousands of federal agents as part of Trump's stringent deportation policy. There, US citizens Renée Good and Alex Pretti were shot by federal agents, and despite clear video footage, the incidents were being covered up. "This US president is covering up with his government that people are being shot on the open street and – although there is clear video footage – the opposite is being told," he said. Such elements are typical of authoritarian systems.

Despite the criticism, Banaszak saw hope: "I believe that in the US we are at least fortunately at the point where decisions might still be reversible." The shootings in Minneapolis sparked outrage and protests, including resistance from school districts against ICE operations.

Apa yang dikatakan orang

Discussions on X criticize Greens co-leader Felix Banaszak's comparison of US ICE agents to Nazi SA and SS as exaggerated and inflammatory. Conservative users mock the rhetoric and counter with historical references to Green Party origins. Media outlets share the news neutrally, noting links to Trump policies and AfD criticism. Sentiments are mostly negative and skeptical, with moderate engagement.

Artikel Terkait

Dramatic illustration of Gov. Tim Walz drawing Civil War parallel during ICE protests in Minneapolis after Renee Good shooting.
Gambar dihasilkan oleh AI

Walz tarik paralel Perang Saudara di tengah protes ICE yang meningkat setelah penembakan Renee Good

Dilaporkan oleh AI Gambar dihasilkan oleh AI

Setelah penembakan fatal terhadap demonstran Renee Good oleh agen ICE di Minneapolis (lihat liputan sebelumnya), Gubernur Tim Walz menyamakan ketegangan penegakan imigrasi federal dengan Perang Saudara. Protes nasional telah meningkat, dengan nyanyian kekerasan menargetkan Sekretaris DHS Kristi Noem, saat dia menegaskan dukungan untuk agen di tengah lonjakan serangan.

Jochen Kopelke, head of the German Police Union (GdP), considers actions like those of the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in the case of killed demonstrator Alex Pretti impossible in Germany. He attributes this to clear legal frameworks and professional police training. Kopelke stresses that deportations are the responsibility of immigration authorities, not the police.

Dilaporkan oleh AI

Presiden Donald Trump mengakui bahwa upaya deportasi massal pemerintahannya mungkin memerlukan pendekatan yang lebih lembut setelah penembakan fatal terhadap dua aktivis anti-ICE di Minneapolis. Insiden tersebut, yang melibatkan agen imigrasi federal yang membunuh Renee Good dan Alex Pretti, memicu perubahan kepemimpinan dan pengurangan kehadiran agen di wilayah tersebut. Pejabat kini menekankan penangkapan terarah di tengah protes yang meningkat dan seruan reformasi.

The US Justice Department has issued subpoenas to Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, Attorney General Keith Ellison, and Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey. The politicians are required to disclose documents on cooperation with immigration authorities. Walz and Frey view this as an intimidation attempt by the Trump administration.

Dilaporkan oleh AI

Gubernur Pennsylvania Josh Shapiro menuduh penegakan imigrasi federal tidak memiliki tujuan sah, mengklaim itu hanya melanggar hak konstitusional. Berbicara di 'The View' ABC, calon potensial Demokrat 2028 berjanji menantang operasi semacam itu di negaranya melalui cara hukum. Pernyataannya datang di tengah insiden mematikan yang melibatkan Patroli Perbatasan di Minneapolis.

Dua hari setelah agen Patroli Perbatasan menembak mati perawat ICU AS yang tidak bersenjata Alex Pretti selama penggerebekan ICE Minneapolis—terekam video menunjukkan ia didesarmasi sebelumnya—reaksi meningkat dengan kritik bipartisan, seruan memecat Sekretaris DHS Kristi Noem, perpecahan internal lembaga, jajak pendapat tidak menguntungkan, dan kekhawatiran penutupan pemerintah terkait dana DHS. Presiden Trump membela Noem sambil mengerahkan czar perbatasan Tom Homan ke negara bagian itu.

Dilaporkan oleh AI Fakta terverifikasi

Juru Bicara Pers Gedung Putih Karoline Leavitt mengkritik para selebriti yang mengutuk Penegakan Imigrasi dan Bea Cukai AS (ICE), dengan alasan mereka mendapat manfaat dari keamanan swasta sambil menyerang agen federal. Pernyataannya datang setelah pesan anti-ICE muncul di Penghargaan Grammy 2026 dan Festival Film Sundance.

 

 

 

Situs web ini menggunakan cookie

Kami menggunakan cookie untuk analisis guna meningkatkan situs kami. Baca kebijakan privasi kami untuk informasi lebih lanjut.
Tolak