NFL draft analyst Todd McShay described North Dakota State quarterback Cole Payton as the most underrated player in the 2026 NFL Draft. On The Rich Eisen Show, McShay predicted Payton would be a Day 2 selection capable of surprising observers. The Pittsburgh Steelers have scouted him extensively, attending his Pro Day and hosting a pre-draft visit.
Pittsburgh Steelers officials have invested time evaluating Cole Payton ahead of the 2026 NFL Draft. The team observed his Pro Day performance and brought him in for a pre-draft visit, signaling potential interest in the quarterback position. Payton, known for his athleticism and strong arm, carries questions about accuracy and mechanics from scouts. An internal scouting report graded him as a Day 3 prospect, drawing comparisons to Tim Tebow for his running ability over passing prowess. Still, McShay highlighted Payton's upside, placing him in a tier with quarterbacks like Penn State's Drew Allar and LSU's Garrett Nussmeier. McShay distinguished Alabama's Ty Simpson as a higher-tier, first-round candidate. Mock drafts have frequently linked Payton to the Steelers, typically in later rounds. Whether Pittsburgh views him as a Day 2 option remains unclear amid other team needs.