South African metros in dispute with auditor-general over audits

The Auditor-General of South Africa has delayed signing off on the 2024-25 audit reports for the cities of Cape Town, Johannesburg, and Ekurhuleni due to formal disputes raised by the municipalities. These delays stem from disagreements over audit interpretations and technical matters, raising concerns about financial governance. Opposition parties have questioned whether the audit outcomes have worsened from the previous year.

The Auditor-General (AG) Tsakani Maluleke has not finalized the 2024-25 audit reports for three major South African metros—Cape Town, Johannesburg, and Ekurhuleni—owing to disputes declared by the cities themselves. AGSA spokesperson Africa Boso confirmed that these matters are being resolved through established dispute procedures, without specifying details or commenting on potential changes in audit opinions until the reports are tabled.

Under the Municipal Finance Management Act, municipalities must submit financial statements by 31 August, with the AG required to deliver audit reports by 30 November. Cape Town submitted its statements on 29 August 2025, but a special AGSA report dated 26 January 2026 cited disputes and technical issues for the delay, pushing the submission deadline from 16 February to 26 February 2026. City spokesperson Luthando Tyhalibongo noted that the city declared a dispute in late January to allow further engagement, emphasizing it is within legislative rights to ensure accurate audit opinions.

In the 2023-24 audits, Cape Town maintained a clean opinion for the third year, while Johannesburg and Ekurhuleni received unqualified opinions with findings. Johannesburg has held this status for 10 years, and Ekurhuleni lost its clean audit in 2022-23 due to financial and governance issues flagged by the AG.

Good party councillor Suzette Little expressed concerns that such delays signal substantive disagreements on matters like revenue recognition or irregular expenditure, potentially affecting investor confidence and credit ratings. ActionSA's Michael Beaumont alleged on 11 February that the metros are regressing in audit outcomes and delaying tabling to amend results, though Cape Town denied any regression, stating the process is ongoing. Johannesburg spokesperson Nthatisi Modingoane said the audit is advanced and they are engaging with AGSA, while Ekurhuleni's Zweli Dlamini declined comment until finalization.

Earlier reports indicated the Johannesburg Stock Exchange warned these cities that their bonds could face suspension if audits are not delivered by month's end.

Связанные статьи

South Africa’s Auditor-General Tsakani Maluleke released a report on 26 March revealing significant delays in 72% of 152 audited infrastructure projects, averaging 41 months. The findings undermine service delivery and President Cyril Ramaphosa’s reform plans amid R47.39-billion in spending. Maluleke urged slowing spending to match capabilities.

Сообщено ИИ

Parliament’s Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs committee has warned the Nelson Mandela Bay Metro it may take further steps due to delayed responses to post-oversight requests. The concerns stem from an October 2025 oversight visit involving multiple municipalities. The metro maintains it submitted the required report on 14 March 2026.

Building on the roller-coaster business year of 2025—which saw Eskom gains, budget battles, and eventual credit upgrades—South Africa begins 2026 with enhanced macroeconomic stability, including reliable power supply and a credit rating upgrade, fostering a more predictable business environment. However, persistent issues like high unemployment, crime, and slow coalition politics limit broader recovery. This balance creates a narrow window for progress rather than a complete turnaround.

Сообщено ИИ

José Antonio Kast's government has decided against proceeding with the international external audit promised during the campaign, citing fiscal resource shortages. It will instead focus on an internal review led by a strategic committee. The Subsecretaría General de la Presidencia confirmed the decision to La Tercera.

 

 

 

Этот сайт использует куки

Мы используем куки для анализа, чтобы улучшить наш сайт. Прочитайте нашу политику конфиденциальности для дополнительной информации.
Отклонить