While Andy Mothibi's appointment as National Director of Public Prosecutions (NDPP) has been praised, commentators like Rebecca Davis have highlighted deep flaws in the selection process, raising questions about transparency in South African public appointments.
Following President Cyril Ramaphosa's announcement on January 7, 2026, of Andy Mothibi—current head of the Special Investigating Unit (SIU)—as the new NDPP effective February 1 (see prior coverage), the decision has drawn mixed reactions. Mothibi's track record, including SIU recoveries of R2.28 billion in 2023/24, positions him well for the role amid NPA challenges like state capture prosecutions.
However, scrutiny persists over the process: a December 2025 panel deemed none of six shortlisted candidates suitable, with its report withheld. Rebecca Davis notes the appointment redeems a flawed mechanism but underscores systemic transparency issues. Reactions vary—OUTA welcomes Mothibi's leadership, while concerns include his age (63) and short tenure until mandatory retirement at 65. The Democratic Alliance has warned of delays. Further examination of appointment procedures is needed to build public trust.
