Gilmar Mendes seeks PGR probe into CPI rapporteur Alessandro Vieira for abuse of authority

In response to a rejected CPI report proposing his indictment, STF Justice Gilmar Mendes on April 15 requested Attorney General Paulo Gonet investigate Senator Alessandro Vieira for abuse of authority, citing deviation from the commission's organized crime focus.

Following the CPI on Organized Crime's rejection of his final report the previous day—which accused STF Justices Gilmar Mendes, Dias Toffoli, and Alexandre de Moraes, plus PGR's Paulo Gonet, of responsibility crimes tied to Banco Master—Justice Mendes filed a five-page representation with the PGR. He argued Vieira's proposal lacked foundations, conflated administrative issues with crimes, exceeded the CPI's remit on militias, laundering, and trafficking, and meddled in judicial calls like habeas corpus.

Mendes highlighted a STF presidential reprimand calling the move an arbitrariness undermining democracy. Vieira retorted: "I won't bow to threats."

Meanwhile, opposition figures like Bia Kicis (PL-DF) and Marcel van Hattem (Novo-RS) urged Justices Luiz Fux and André Mendonça at the STF about perceived congressional attacks, with Kicis claiming "war" between branches.

This escalates tensions in the Maridt Participações and Banco Master secrecy disputes under CPI scrutiny, following STF rulings upholding detentions and denying appeals on secrecy lifts.

Liittyvät artikkelit

Dramatic illustration of Brazil's CPI rejecting a report against STF justices in a 6-4 Senate vote.
AI:n luoma kuva

Brazil's organized crime CPI rejects report against STF justices

Raportoinut AI AI:n luoma kuva

Brazil's Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry (CPI) on Organized Crime rejected Senator Alessandro Vieira's (MDB-SE) final report on Tuesday (April 14), which proposed indicting three Supreme Federal Court (STF) justices and the Attorney General. The report was defeated 6-4 after changes in the commission's composition. The substitutions favored government-aligned members, swaying the vote outcome.

STF President Edson Fachin rejected a Senate CPI of Organized Crime's appeal against Justice Gilmar Mendes' earlier suspension of secrecy breaks on Maridt Participações, a firm linked to Justice Dias Toffoli. This keeps the company's banking, fiscal, phone, and telematic records sealed amid probes into financial irregularities and possible organized crime ties.

Raportoinut AI

The president of the CPMI do INSS, Senator Carlos Viana, announced he will appeal the STF decision allowing banker Daniel Vorcaro not to testify before the commission. The Federal Police presented updates on the Banco Master investigations to Minister André Mendonça in a meeting on Monday. Lawmakers criticize delays in sending broken secrecy documents to the CPI.

STF Minister André Mendonça ruled on Monday (March 23) that the Court's plenary analyze the endorsement of the preliminary injunction extending the INSS CPMI's work. He ordered Senate President Davi Alcolumbre to read the extension request within 48 hours. The decision responds to lawmakers investigating frauds in pension benefits.

Raportoinut AI

Minister Dias Toffoli stepped down from the Master case relatoria at the STF after a closed meeting with other ministers, convened by President Edson Fachin due to a Police Federal report arguing his suspicion. The Court issued a joint note stating no impediment exists, and the relatoria was reassigned to André Mendonça. Parties and police delegates' associations reacted in defense of judicial institutionalism.

The government-allied base presented an alternative report in the INSS CPMI on Friday (March 27), seeking indictment of 130 people, including former president Jair Bolsonaro and Senator Flávio Bolsonaro (PL-RJ), for billion-dollar pension frauds. The document counters the official report by relator Alfredo Gaspar (União Brasil-AL), which calls for indicting 216 names, including President Lula's son, Fábio Luís Lula da Silva (Lulinha). Voting is due by Saturday (March 28).

Raportoinut AI

The STF's Second Panel ruled 4-0 to uphold the preventive detention of Banco Master owner Daniel Vorcaro on Friday (March 20). Justice Gilmar Mendes sided with rapporteur André Mendonça but criticized the reasoning as using 'porous and elastic' terms. The ruling comes amid Operation Compliance Zero probing financial frauds.

 

 

 

Tämä verkkosivusto käyttää evästeitä

Käytämme evästeitä analyysiä varten parantaaksemme sivustoamme. Lue tietosuojakäytäntömme tietosuojakäytäntö lisätietoja varten.
Hylkää