James L. Brooks' comedy 'Ella McCay,' starring Emma Mackey as a young politician, has garnered mixed reviews from critics. The film explores themes of idealism and family dysfunction set against a political backdrop in 2008. While praising the ensemble cast, reviewers note its overly sentimental tone and disconnect from real-world politics.
Overview
'Ella McCay' is a comedy written and directed by James L. Brooks, known for films like 'Terms of Endearment' and television series such as 'The Mary Tyler Moore Show.' The story centers on Ella McCay (Emma Mackey), who becomes governor of an unnamed state at age 34. Set in 2008, the narrative portrays a more optimistic era, as voiced by narrator Julie Kavner. Ella's idealism clashes with her dysfunctional family, including her father Eddie (Woody Harrelson), aunt Helen (Jamie Lee Curtis), husband Ryan (Jack Lowden), and brother Casey (Spike Fearn).
Plot Details
Ella, initially lieutenant governor, implements quirky policies like dissolving phone banks for constituent focus and a 'Tooth Tutors' dental plan. Her ascent is complicated by personal setbacks, including her mother's death (Rebecca Hall) and family scandals. As governor, she faces blackmail from a reporter and seeks reconciliation with her father. The film draws Frank Capra influences but emphasizes character flaws and optimism, with supporting roles from Kumail Nanjiani as driver Trooper Nash, Ayo Edebiri as Casey's ex Susan, and Albert Brooks as ex-governor Bill Moore.
Production and Release
Produced by Gracie Films for 20th Century Studios, the film features cinematography by Robert Elswit, editing by Tracey Wadmore-Smith, and music by Hans Zimmer. It runs 115 minutes and carries a PG-13 rating. Screened at El Capitan Theater in Los Angeles on December 10, 2025, 'Ella McCay' aims to celebrate imperfect idealists in a cynical world.
Critical Reception
Reviews highlight the strong cast performances, particularly Mackey's portrayal of a perfectionistic leader. However, critics from The Hollywood Reporter and Variety describe the characters as phony and the dialogue as overly polished, lacking realism. Some see it as a misfire compared to Brooks' past successes, with outdated political views and unnecessary subplots. Despite flaws, the film's earnest heart and humor resonate in parts.
