菲律宾大学环境科学与气象研究所发出警告:Monterrazas 洪水研究存在局限性

菲律宾大学环境科学与气象研究所(IESM)提醒公众,不要将其洪水模拟研究解读为对宿务2025年“蒂诺”(Tino)台风灾难责任的定论。此前,网红工程师 Slater Young 发布视频,援引该研究声称其负责的 Monterrazas de Cebu 项目并非造成此次导致百余人死亡的洪灾原因。IESM 向 Philstar.com 强调,该分析基于特定的假设和设定的界限。

菲律宾大学环境科学与气象研究所(IESM)针对由 Mayzonee Ligaray 博士领导的环境水文学实验室所开展的洪水模拟研究,向 Philstar.com 发表了声明。IESM 指出,与所有科学研究一样,该分析基于特定的假设、既定的模型边界和特定的研究目标,因此其研究结果必须在上述语境下解读。研究所明确表示,该研究结果“既不认定也不排除任何相关方的责任”。

4月19日,网红工程师、Mont Property Group 旗下 Monterrazas de Cebu 高端山坡项目联合创始人 Slater Young 发布视频,援引菲律宾大学的这项研究作为证据,声称该开发项目并未引发或加剧“蒂诺”台风带来的洪灾。尽管未点名 Young,但 IESM 强调了“在适当的技术范畴内,并结合更广泛的多学科及社区因素来解读科学发现的重要性”。

Ligaray 于4月21日向 Rappler 表示,该研究尚未完成。3月2日在社交媒体上分享的研究结果仅涵盖了六个流域中的两个——瓜达卢佩(Guadalupe)和基纳鲁姆桑(Kinalumsan),其余四个流域的研究尚在进行中。在接受环境媒体 Sustina 采访时,她表示该研究并非环境影响评估,并提到 Monterrazas 的滞洪池“起到了缓冲作用”,但同时也指出,全流域洪水涉及其他分水岭及洪水模型的复杂因素。

菲律宾环境与自然资源部(DENR)在发现该项目违反了其环境合规证书中33项条件中的10项(包括排水系统不足)后,曾暂时叫停了 Monterrazas 的运营。DENR 第7大区办公室随后解除了停工令,解除时间恰逢 Young 发布视频的那个周末。

相关文章

The Department of Environment and Natural Resources has lifted the cease of operations order against the Monterrazas de Cebu project, blamed for extreme flooding during Typhoon Tino last year. The Environmental Management Bureau in Central Visayas said the project proponent, The Mont Property Group Inc., implemented required corrective measures under its Environmental Compliance Certificate. EMB regional director John Edward Ang cited documented remedial works, compliance milestones, and settled penalties under Presidential Decree 1586.

由 AI 报道

The investigating judge in the 2024 DANA case criticized in a Monday ruling the lack of coordination by Carlos Mazón's Consell during the October 29 emergency, which killed 230 people. She describes the Es-Alert as very late and erroneous, sent after many deaths. She highlights the failure to deploy resources like environmental agents.

Wetlands International Philippines warned on Monday, March 30, against renewed oil and gas exploration in Ligawasan Marsh amid the energy crisis stemming from the Middle East. The group stated that unregulated activities could contaminate one of the country's most biodiverse wetlands, worsen flooding, and release stored carbon. They urged the government to prioritize renewable energy over risking fragile ecosystems.

由 AI 报道

Former House speaker and Leyte Rep. Martin Romualdez has moved to disqualify the Office of the Ombudsman from probing his alleged involvement in the flood control controversy, warning of a ‘pattern of prejudgment’ that violates due process. In a four-page letter dated April 22, his lawyers argued that statements by Ombudsman Jesus Crispin Remulla show prosecution for plunder was decided in advance. He seeks handling by a neutral official.

此网站使用 cookie

我们使用 cookie 进行分析以改进我们的网站。阅读我们的 隐私政策 以获取更多信息。
拒绝