Senator Murphy criticizes incoherent US war plans against Iran

Democratic Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut described the Trump administration's plans for the ongoing war in Iran as 'incoherent and incomplete' following a closed-door briefing. He highlighted conflicting statements on war aims and urged Congress to end the conflict by denying funding. The war has led to significant civilian casualties and global oil disruptions due to Iran's closure of the Strait of Hormuz.

The United States is engaged in a war with Iran, initiated by the Trump administration, which has prompted sharp criticism from Democratic lawmakers. In an NPR interview on March 12, 2026, Senator Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) stated that administration officials in a recent briefing clarified that military operations are not targeting Iran's nuclear sites and are not pursuing regime change. This contrasts with President Trump's public statements aiming to end Iran's nuclear program, achieve unconditional surrender, and select Iran's next leader.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio publicly outlined war goals as eliminating Iran's missile capacity and navy, while also claiming the U.S. did not initiate the conflict but responded to defend interests from blowback of a planned Israeli strike. Murphy described these varying rationales as incoherent, noting daily shifts in justifications for starting the war. A Slate podcast episode from the same day discussed how Iran's closure of the Strait of Hormuz has caused oil prices to skyrocket, with potential U.S. gas prices reaching $5 per gallon, amid opaque U.S. war aims.

A Pentagon investigation confirmed that a U.S. tomahawk missile struck a girls' school near an Iranian naval base, killing more than 100 people, despite Trump's denials and suggestions that Iran might have fired the missile itself. Murphy condemned the president's lies, arguing that air campaigns lead to civilian deaths that harden opposition and elect more anti-American leaders, as seen in past conflicts like Afghanistan and Iraq.

Murphy warned that failing to achieve regime change could leave Iran with a more provocative government and remnants of its nuclear program, alongside historic oil flow disruptions lasting months. He advocated ending the war immediately, rejecting ground troop involvement, and called on Congress—controlled by Republicans—to debate a war declaration and withhold funding. Trump told Axios, 'anytime I want it to end, it will end,' but Murphy contested the president's unilateral war powers, emphasizing the foreseeable risks of Hormuz closure and limited regime change prospects from intelligence estimates.

Artikel Terkait

Dramatic illustration of US and Israeli airstrikes on Iranian naval and missile targets in the Persian Gulf, with inset of slain Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, amid day five of Operation Epic Fury.
Gambar dihasilkan oleh AI

AS dan Israel eskalasi perang melawan Iran pada hari kelima

Dilaporkan oleh AI Gambar dihasilkan oleh AI

AS dan Israel melanjutkan operasi militer melawan Iran pada 4 Maret 2026, memasuki hari kelima konflik yang dikenal sebagai Operasi Epic Fury. Serangan tersebut menargetkan aset angkatan laut Iran, kemampuan rudal, dan kepemimpinan, termasuk pembunuhan Pemimpin Tertinggi Ayatollah Ali Khamenei. Kritik meningkat atas kurangnya persetujuan kongres dan rencana evakuasi bagi warga Amerika di wilayah tersebut.

Ruang udara Iran ditutup pada malam Rabu di tengah tanda-tanda serangan AS yang akan segera terjadi, tetapi tidak ada serangan yang terjadi, membuat para ahli menggambarkannya sebagai bagian dari ketidakpastian khas Presiden Trump. Aset militer dipindahkan dan basis sebagian dievakuasi, namun Trump mengubah nada suaranya, menyatakan bahwa pembunuhan di Iran telah berhenti. Analis memandang ini sebagai operasi psikologis untuk membingungkan Teheran sementara pasukan AS memposisikan ulang.

Dilaporkan oleh AI

Iran has stated it will decide when the war with the US and Israel ends, emphasizing no oil will be shipped out of the Middle East if attacks continue. President Donald Trump said the war will end in four weeks or sooner. However, Iran's military insists there must be a winner and calls Trump's statement nonsense.

Presiden Trump membenarkan serangan AS terhadap program nuklir Iran meskipun harga minyak melebihi $100 per barel, setelah serangan Iran terhadap tanker yang mengganggu pengiriman di Teluk Persia. Ia memprioritaskan pencegahan persenjataan nuklir Iran daripada biaya energi jangka pendek, sambil mengumumkan langkah-langkah lebih lanjut untuk menurunkan harga bensin AS.

Dilaporkan oleh AI

Pada 28 Februari 2026, Amerika Serikat dan Israel melakukan serangan militer terkoordinasi terhadap Iran, menargetkan situs nuklir, rudal balistik, dan kepemimpinan rezim dalam operasi yang dijuluki Operasi Kemarahan Epik. Presiden Donald Trump mengumumkan aksi tersebut dalam video berdurasi delapan menit, mendesak warga Iran untuk menggulingkan pemerintah mereka setelah serangan selesai. Pejabat Iran membalas dengan peluncuran misil ke Israel dan basis AS di Bahrain, meskipun tidak ada korban jiwa yang dilaporkan.

Israel's Ambassador Ron Prosor warns against Western support for the Iranian regime and demands determination to weaken it. He criticizes negotiations with US President Donald Trump as stalling tactics. The regime is at a crossroads but will not fall on its own.

Dilaporkan oleh AI

Four days after initial US and Israeli strikes on Iran sparked regional escalation on February 28, the conflict intensified with Israel destroying Iran's state television headquarters in Tehran, Iranian missile and drone attacks on US and Israeli targets, and the threatened closure of the Strait of Hormuz.

 

 

 

Situs web ini menggunakan cookie

Kami menggunakan cookie untuk analisis guna meningkatkan situs kami. Baca kebijakan privasi kami untuk informasi lebih lanjut.
Tolak